Journal · DIY
DIY maintenance mistakes small business owners make (and how to avoid them)
Nine DIY WordPress maintenance mistakes small business owners make, from updating everything at once to panic-fixing warnings, and the simple habit that avoids each.
A while ago, Google Search Console emailed me about my own website. It said pages weren’t being indexed: “Blocked due to other 4xx issue”. It’s the kind of email that makes your heart sink.
My first instinct was to start fixing. Instead, I opened the report and looked at exactly which address it named. There was only one: a WordPress background file that isn’t a page at all and is meant to stay out of Google. No real page was affected. I ran Google’s live test to confirm it, and changed nothing.
That’s the quiet truth about looking after your own website. Most damage doesn’t come from hackers. It comes from small, well-meant habits: fixing what isn’t broken, skipping what is, and not checking afterwards.
If you’re a coach, therapist, tutor or consultant looking after your own WordPress site, here are nine DIY maintenance mistakes I see again and again, and the simple habit that avoids each one.
I’ve looked after WordPress websites since 2018, and before that I was an IT technician at a sixth form college in Bethnal Green.
1. Updating everything at once, with no backup
It’s tempting: you log in, see twelve updates waiting, and click “Update all”. If something breaks, you won’t know which update caused it, and you won’t have a way back.
The habit: take a backup first, keep it somewhere other than your website, then update a few things at a time, starting with the ones that matter least.
Here’s how to back up your WordPress site yourself, step by step.
2. Not checking the site afterwards
An update can look fine on the dashboard and still break something on the page. On one coach’s site I look after, the contact forms started showing as a line of raw code instead of a form, because a plugin the site relied on had been switched off. Nothing on the dashboard said “your forms are broken”.
The habit: after any update or change, open your homepage, your contact page and your booking page. Send yourself a test message. Click your booking link. Five minutes, every time.
Here’s the 2-minute contact form test I use.
3. Leaving updates for months
The opposite mistake is just as common. Updates often include security fixes, so the longer you leave them, the longer known weaknesses stay open. And when you finally do update, there’s a lot more that can go wrong at once.
The habit: pick a regular slot, say every Monday morning or the first working day of the month, and keep it.
My WordPress update schedule guide suggests how often to update plugins, themes and core.
4. Keeping plugins and themes you don’t use
A switched-off plugin isn’t the same as a removed one. Its files still sit on your hosting, and if it has a known weakness, it can still be a way in. The same goes for old themes you tried once in 2021.
The habit: if you haven’t used it in months and your site works without it, back up, then delete it. Keep one spare default theme as a fallback.
5. Keeping backups only on your hosting
Many hosts take backups, which is great. But if your hosting has a serious problem, or your account is locked, those backups can be out of reach at exactly the moment you need them.
The habit: keep at least one copy somewhere else, such as Google Drive or Dropbox, and check once a month that new backups are still arriving.
More on this in my WordPress backup strategy guide.
6. One shared login, an old password, no two-factor
Lots of small businesses have one admin login that the owner, a past VA and a friend who “helped with the website” all know. Often the password hasn’t changed in years.
The habit:
- Give every person their own login, with only the access they need.
- Remove people who no longer help you.
- Use a unique password for every admin account (a password manager makes this painless).
- Switch on two-factor login, so a code from your phone is needed as well as the password.
If you’re choosing a plugin for that last one, see my guide to the best WordPress security plugins for small UK businesses.
7. Letting the domain or hosting renewal slip
This one is painfully ordinary. The card on your domain account expires, the renewal fails, the reminder emails go to an old inbox, and one morning your website and your business email stop working.
The habit: check which email address your domain and hosting accounts use, update the card on file, and switch on auto-renew. Put the renewal dates in your diary too.
If it has already happened, here’s what to do when your domain expires and your email stops.
8. Panic-fixing a warning before reading it
As in my Search Console story above: not every scary email is a real problem. Some warnings name files that are meant to be hidden, or issues that don’t affect visitors at all. Rushing to “fix” them can break something that was fine.
The habit: before you change anything, read exactly what the warning names (which page, which file, which plugin) and whether it affects what your visitors see. If you’re unsure, take a screenshot and ask someone before you act.
9. Adding a plugin for every small problem
Site feels slow? Install a speed plugin. Worried about security? Install two security plugins. Want a pop-up? Another plugin. Each one adds code, settings and things to update, and some clash with each other.
The habit: before installing anything, ask whether your host or an existing plugin already does the job. One well set-up tool beats three half set-up ones. And never run two plugins that do the same job (two caching plugins, or two firewalls, for example).
Bonus: forgetting the engine under the bonnet
Your site runs on software called PHP, which your host provides. Old versions stop getting security fixes. WordPress recommends PHP 8.3 or newer and warns that older versions may expose your site to security risks.
The habit: once a year, check your PHP version in your hosting panel (or ask your host). Take a backup before changing it, then check your pages afterwards, because some older plugins and themes don’t like newer versions.
A simple monthly routine
If you’d like all of this as one routine, here’s a 20-minute version for the first working day of each month:
- Check a recent backup exists, and that a copy is stored away from your hosting.
- Take a fresh backup.
- Update WordPress, then plugins, then your theme, a few at a time.
- Check your homepage, contact page and booking page. Send a test message.
- Delete anything you no longer use.
- Glance at your domain and hosting renewal dates.
For the fuller version, here’s a monthly website health check: 12 things to look at.
If your site also feels slow, my plain-English guide to speeding up a WordPress website is a good next read.
FAQ
What’s the most common WordPress maintenance mistake?
The one I’d put first is not checking the site after an update. The update itself often goes fine; it’s the form or booking link that quietly stops working that causes the real trouble.
Is it safe to turn on automatic updates?
It can be, especially for small security updates to WordPress itself. The risk is that something breaks while you’re not looking. If you switch on automatic updates, keep backups running and check your key pages regularly.
How long does DIY WordPress maintenance take?
As a rough guide, for a typical small service business site, about 20 to 30 minutes a month if you follow a routine, plus a little extra when something needs fixing.
When should I stop doing it myself?
When it starts taking time you’d rather give your clients or your family, or when you notice you’re putting it off. Doing it yourself is perfectly reasonable, as long as it actually gets done.
Not sure where your site stands? Start with a free Website Check
Send me your website address and I’ll look it over and tell you, in plain words, what’s working and what’s holding it back. It arrives within 24 to 48 hours, Monday to Friday. Nothing to sign, no call needed, and nothing on your site gets changed.
Whenever you’re ready, I’m here.
Tell me a little about where you are and where you’d like to be. I’ll reply personally.